| YEAR | LAST NAME | FIRST NAME | SPORT | TYPE AWARD | LEVEL AWARD | MAJOR |
| 2009 | Butler | Drew | FB | Team | District 1st Team | Telecommunications |
| Caprioglio | Lisa | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | International Business | |
| Egan | John | TF | Team | National 3rd Team | Sport Management/Telecommunications | |
| Lyons | Bridget | TF | Team | District 1st Team | Biology/Spanish | |
| McQuinn | Ilana | TF | Team | District 2nd Team | Comparative Literature/History | |
| Sandberg | Kristyn | SB | Team | District 2nd Team | Health and Physical Education | |
| Schlopy | Taylor | SB | Team | District 2nd Team | Child and Family Development | |
| Stein | Lindsay | SC | Team | District 3rd Team | Biological Science | |
| Taylor | Grace | GYM | At-Large | National 1st Team | Psychology | |
| Trott | Wendy | SW | At-Large | District 1st Team | International Affairs | |
| 2008 | Caprioglio | Lisa | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | International Business |
| Chapas | Shaun | FB | Team | District 1st Team | Marketing | |
| Durham | Kris | FB | Team | District 1st Team | Middle School Education | |
| Egan | John | TF | Team | District 1st Team | Sport Management/Telecommunications | |
| Kupets | Courtney | GYM | At-Large | National 1st Team | Housing | |
| Lyons | Bridget | TF | Team | District 2nd Team | Biology/Spansih | |
| Peters | Annalise | TF | Team | District 2nd Team | International Affairs | |
| Taylor | Grace | GYM | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Psychology | |
| Taylor | Maria | VB | Team | District 3rd Team | Broadcast News | |
| Schlopy | Taylor | GYM | Team | District 2nd Team | Child and Family Development | |
| 2007 | Beckham | Gordon | BB | Team | National 2nd Team | Real Estate |
| Burrell | Ian | TF | Team | National 1st Team | Criminal Justice | |
| Guilkey | Karen | SW | At-Large | District 1st Team | Exercise and Sport Science | |
| Harman | Brian | GF | At-Large | District 2nd Team | Finance | |
| Kapurch | Joseph | SW | At-Large | National 3rd Team | Cellular Biology | |
| Kupets | Courtney | GYM | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Housing | |
| Mimbs | Brian | FB | Team | District 1st Team | Risk Managment | |
| Picchetti | Natalie | TF | Team | District 2nd Team | Psychology | |
| Taylor | Grace | GYM | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Psychology | |
| 2006 | Bruce | Catherine | SC | Team | District 3rd Team | Speech Communication |
| Burks | Lauren | TF | Team | District 2nd Team | Biology & Spanish | |
| Burlingame | Brooke | VB | Team | District 3rd Team | Business | |
| Carroll | Kasi | SB | Team | National 1st Team | Early Childhood Education | |
| Heffelfinger | Kristin | TF | Team | District 2nd Team | English & Art History | |
| Stibrich | Nathan | SW | At-Large | District 2nd Team | Chemistry | |
| 2005 | Arsenault | Samantha | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | Science Education |
| Burks | Lauren | XC | Team | District 2nd Team | Biology & Spanish | |
| Lewis | Katie | SB | Team | National 2nd Team | Biology | |
| 2004 | Burks | Lauren | XC | Team | District 2nd Team | Biology & Spanish |
| Lewis | Katie | SB | Team | District 1st Team | Biology | |
| Lindley | Ashley | SC | Team | District | Biology | |
| Martinez | Celly | TF | Team | National 1st Team | Economics & Political Science | |
| Rowe | Kinsey | GYM | At-Large | District 2nd Team | Mathematics & Physics (Minor) | |
| Underhill | Colin | SW | At-Large | District 2nd Team | Finance | |
| 2003 | Drakulich | Corrin | TF | Team | National 1st Team | Genetics & Religion |
| Lindley | Ashley | SC | Team | District 1st Team | Biology | |
| Pare | Virginia | SW | At-Large | District 3rd Team | Mathematics | |
| Rowe | Kinsey | GYM | At-Large | District 3rd Team | Mathematics | |
| 2002 | Drakulich | Corrin | TF | Team | National 3rd Team | Genetics |
| Greene | David | FB | Team | District | Management | |
| Kirouac | Brett | FB | Team | District | Finance & Religion (Minor) | |
| Lindsay | Marc | SW | At-Large | District 1st Team | English & Polical Science | |
| Seibert | Jacqueline | TF | Team | District 1st Team | Exercise & Sports Science | |
| Stinchcomb | Jon | FB | Team | National 1st Team | Microbiology & Religion (Minor) | |
| Tull | Aisha | TF | Team | District 2nd Team | Speech Communication | |
| 2001 | Black | Kim | SW | At-Large | All-American of the Year | Biology |
| Kirouac | Brett | FB | Team | District | Finance | |
| Lindsay | Marc | SW | At-Large | National 2nd Team | English & Polical Science | |
| Miller | Coco | BKB | Team | National 3rd Team | Biology | |
| Miller | Kelly | BKB | Team | National 2nd Team | Biology | |
| Stinchcomb | Jon | FB | Team | National 1st Team | Microbiology | |
| 2000 | Black | Kim | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | Biology |
| Miller | Coco | BKB | Team | District | Biology | |
| Miller | Kelly | BKB | Team | National 2nd Team | Biology | |
| Ogg | Shannon | GF | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Finance & Risk Management / Insurance | |
| Stinchcomb | Jon | FB | Team | National 2nd Team | Microbiology | |
| 1999 | Beathard | Jenni | GYM | At-Large | National 2nd Team | |
| Hays | Chris | BB | Team | District 2nd Team | Social Science Education | |
| Miller | Sarah | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | Biology | |
| Pitts | Joey | TN | At-Large | National 1st Team | Biology | |
| 1998 | Baldas | Steven | TN | At-Large | National 1st Team | Finance |
| Boros | Julia | GF | At-Large | National 1st Team | Finance | |
| Brill | Cassie | VB | Team | National 3rd Team | Management | |
| Hales | Chad | XC | At-Large | National 1st Team | Biochemistry & Molecular Biology | |
| 1998 | Miller | Sarah | SW | At-Large | District 1st Team | Biology |
| Pitts | Joey | TN | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Biology | |
| Shannon | Lance | BB | Team | National 2nd Team | Management | |
| Smart | Kirby | FB | Team | National 2nd Team | Finance | |
| Stinchcomb | Matt | FB | Team | National 1st Team | Finance | |
| Watson | Tracy | XC | At-Large | District 2nd Team | Biology | |
| 1997 | Boros | Julia | GF | At-Large | National 3rd Team | Finance |
| Brill | Cassie | VB | Team | District | Business | |
| Coole | Lisa | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | Biology | |
| DeVooght | Andrew | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | Political Science | |
| Dickinson | Allison | VB | Team | District | Exercise & Sports Science | |
| Sipe | Trey | FB | Team | District | Biological Engineering | |
| Smart | Kirby | FB | Team | District | Finance | |
| Stinchcomb | Matt | FB | Team | National 1st Team | Business | |
| Wynn | Barry | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | Management | |
| 1996 | Blackmon | Heather | SW | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Biology |
| Coole | Lisa | SW | At-Large | District | Biology | |
| DeVooght | Andrew | SW | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Political Science | |
| Smart | Kirby | FB | Team | District | Finance | |
| Stinchcomb | Matt | FB | Team | District | Business | |
| Woodend | Dianne | XC | At-Large | District | Dietetics | |
| 1995 | Blackmon | Heather | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | Biology |
| DeVooght | Andrew | SW | At-Large | District | Political Science | |
| Nicholson | Nikki | VB | Team | All-American of the Year | Microbiology | |
| Wynn | Barry | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | Business | |
| 1994 | Kruse | Jodi | VB | Team | National 1st Team | Middle School Education |
| Nicholson | Nikki | VB | Team | All-American of the Year | Microbiology | |
| Wynn | Barry | SW | At-Large | National 3rd Team | Arts and Sciences | |
| 1993 | Carbone | Jennifer | GYM | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Biology |
| Kruse | Jodi | VB | Team | National 1st Team | Middle School Education | |
| Nicholson | Nikki | VB | Team | National 2nd Team | Pre-Medicine | |
| Wilson | Paige | SW | At-Large | District | Finance | |
| 1992 | Carbone | Jennifer | FGYM | At-Large | National 1st Team | Biology |
| Kruse | Jodi | VB | Team | National 2nd Team | Middle School Education | |
| Moore | Jill | VB | Team | National 1st Team | Mathematics | |
| 1991 | Carbone | Jennifer | GYM | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Biology |
| Moore | Jill | VB | Team | National 1st Team | Mathematics | |
| Parker | Al | TN | At-Large | All-American of the Year | ||
| Taormina | Sheila | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | ||
| 1990 | Childs | Jim | TN | At-Large | National 1st Team | Accounting |
| Kessler | Alec | BKB | Team | All-American of the Year* | ||
| Moore | Jill | VB | Team | National 2nd Team | Biology | |
| Parker | Al | TN | At-Large | All-American of the Year | Finance | |
| Taormina | Sheila | SW | At-Large | National 3rd Team | Industrial Relations | |
| Waldman | Jill | TN | At-Large | National 3rd Team | Public Relations | |
| 1988 | Bebeau | Lianna | TN | At-Large | National 1st Team | Finance |
| Leith | Linda | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | Chemistry | |
| 1987 | Leith | Linda | SW | At-Large | National 1st Team | Chemistry |
| Thomas | Laura Lynn | SW | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Marketing | |
| 1986 | Leith | Linda | SW | At-Large | District | Chemistry |
| 1985 | Thomas | Laura Lynn | SW | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Accounting |
| 1984 | McMinn | Kathryn | GYM | At-Large | National 2nd Team | Biochemistry |
| Perkins | Sandy | VB | Team | District 2nd Team | Pre-Medicine |